The Sixth Thing that's Wrong

Ken Eckerty has posted a website entitled "Why I left the Organized Church" (http://www.savior-of-all.com/organized.html). It gives 10 or more reasons, and I'd like to take them on. The sixth thing that's wrong:

Emphasis on old Covenant law, especially tithing, that breeds guilt.

Christianity is a faith based on liberty, yet its members have declared Jesus Christ to be Lord. That creates a unique tension. Can those who obey also be free? Some Christians assume that freedom in Christ is just a new version of living by the rules. Thus they serve up heavy doses of Israel's law, modified it somewhat to match the teaching of Jesus. They fail to understand that, for the Christian, the law is internalized. It's not a matter of obeying rules but actually of being new people whose desire is to find the pattern of life Jesus set out for them. Learning to be new people is not a matter of figuring out the rules and then obeying them. It's a matter of discovering that new life in Jesus means that our whole approach to life has changed, that we actually want to be like Jesus.

The tithing issue is a challenge to churches. The tithe in Israel's faith before Jesus was set within the rules, and it ensured at steady income to keep the temple and priesthood operating. If churches say that giving is no longer a rule, they risk not getting the income. So some of them drag out the tithe and make it a Christian rule, alienating those who reject the notion that going to church means you have to pay for the privilege. Christian giving isn't supposed to be anything like that. If you belong to Jesus, all you have belongs to him too. He's given it to you to use, so giving is nothing more than a grateful response to his goodness. Churches need not fear if they drop the tithing rule. Those who love Jesus and his work will give to it. Those who don't want to give should be able to worship for free. The tithe is not the price of admission.

Which leads me to ask the church: Have we forgotten liberty because we so much want our people to do the right thing? Have we introduced Christian rules as a substitute for Christian transformation?